Answering Your Calls 24/7
Toll free: 888-352-0338

Two reasons corporation shareholders sue

Shareholders, it’s often said, are ultimately the owners of a corporation, so it might seem odd that they’d ever file a lawsuit against that corporation or their fellow shareholders.

Still, such legal disputes between shareholders are surprisingly common. Lawsuits involving corporate finances are notoriously complex, but here are two simplified examples to help illustrate why such lawsuits happen.

Deceit or false projections

In 2013, billionaire David Murdock took over Dole Foods, which had been a public company. He “took it private” by offering the board of directors $1.6 billion to let him buy up the company stock then owned by the public. It apparently seemed like a fair price at the time, and the board accepted his offer.

But it turned out that Murdock and the company’s general counsel had, allegedly, hidden positive information about the company’s future, allowing Murdock to low-ball the price he’d paid for the company stock.

The former stockholders sued and won. The judge found that the failure to disclose positive information about Dole’s potential for future earnings was a way to unfairly keep the price down, and to keep Murdock’s profits up. He was guilty, the court found, of a “breach of loyalty.”

Poor governance

Early this year, shareholders filed a lawsuit against Google’s parent company, Alphabet, alleging that the company had paid huge exit packages to executives who were leaving the company due to allegations of sexual misconduct.

Instead of firing the executives for their wrongdoing and reforming the corporate culture, the companies exercised its contractual right to force the executives into secret deal-making (that is, arbitration) and leave quietly with a large payout, according to the suit.

Once this strategy was revealed, 20,000 Google employees staged a walkout late last year. For shareholders’ part, the company’s motto of “Don’t be evil” had long been a selling point for Google stock. Compromising the company’s ethical reputation therefore degraded the value of company stock.

The lawsuit alleges that top executives mismanaged the company and file the suit for what essentially amounts to business malpractice on the part of corporate governance.

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information
Logo Icon

Contact Edgar Law Firm LLC To Discuss Your Case

For additional information or to schedule a consultation with a lawyer, please call us toll free: 888-352-0338. You may also contact us via email.

*Evening and weekend appointments are available by pre-arrangement.

Close Personal Attention From A Law Firm With A National Scope

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.


Privacy Policy

  • The National Trial Lawyers Top 100
  • Super Lawyers | IAG
  • Best Of The Bar | Kansas City Business Journal
  • American Board Of Trial Advocates
  • Multi Million Doller Advocates Forum

Our Office Locations

Kansas City Office
2600 Grand Blvd.
Suite 440
Kansas City, MO 64108

Toll Free: 888-352-0338
Phone: 816-399-5158
Fax: 816-531-3322
Map & Directions

Denver Office
216 16th Street
Suite 850
Denver, CO 80202

Toll Free: 888-352-0338
Phone: 720-529-0505
Fax: 303-486-0001
Map & Directions

Denver Foothills Office
3092 Evergreen Parkway
Suite 102
Evergreen, CO 80439

Toll Free: 888-352-0338
Phone: 720-638-4105
Map & Directions

Los Angeles Office
233 Wilshire Blvd
Suite 900
Santa Monica, CA 90401

Toll Free: 888-352-0338
Phone: 310-984-6888
Map & Directions

St. Louis Office
950 Francis Place
Suite 107
St. Louis, MO 63105

Toll Free: 888-352-0338
Phone: 314-219-7832
Map & Directions